Venturi House

The Venturi House was built by Venturi for his mother. This house recognizes complexities and contradictions. It is both “complex and simple, open and closed, big and little.” It achieves the difficult task of unifying such diverse parts.

When looking at the front facade of the Venturi house, it acts as a billboard for the nature of the building. The triangular roof clearly advertises this building as a home. Although the outside seems simple at first glance, a second look reveals complexities in the deceivingly minimalist design on both the outside and the inside. Widely considered to be the first postmodernist house, the Venturi house displays nonfunctional, even historical elements such as the arch motif – clearly breaking another modernist principle.

If we look at the interior, tension is centralized in the core of the house where the fireplace, the chimney, and the stair all compete for a dominant position. On one side, the fireplace and chimney distort in shape and shift in location, while on the other side the staircase constricts in width distorting the path.

We can clearly see that tension is a preference of Venturi, he says that “contradictory relationships express tension and give vitality. A valid architecture evokes many levels of meaning; its space and its elements become readable and workable in several ways at once”, so his manipulation of space is deliberate in order to achieve this meaningful relationship.

The architectural complexities and distortions inside are reflected on the seemingly simple outside. The varying locations, sizes, and shapes of the windows, as well as the off center location of the chimney, contradict the overall symmetry of the outside form and speak to the dynamic composition of the interior.

Venturi says; “I like elements which are hybrid rather than pure, compromising rather than clean, distorted rather than straightforward, ambiguous rather than articulated, perverse as well as impersonal, boring as well as interesting”.

This is also reflected in the fact that it is a little house with oversized elements. For example the fireplace in considered too big and the mantel too high in relative proportion to the size of the room.

In back, the lunette window is big and dominating in shape and position. In front, the entrance is wide, high, and central. Its’ big size is emphasized by the contrast with the other smaller doors and windows.

The setting of the house is a flat open interior site, enclosed by trees. The house sits in the center with no foliage. Within its setting, the abstract composition of this building almost equally combines rectangular, diagonal, and curving elements in a balanced, interactive, dialogue.

When we look at the post modern complex design of the Venturi house, we can clearly see why Venturi argues for the post modern. The postmodern juxtaposition of elements challenges the eye with its’ contradictions and gives “meaning, vitality, and validity” to architecture.

 

Venturi’s Complexity and Contradiction in Architecture

As a group we analyzed Venturi and his guiding principles in which he created his revolutionary post modernist structures.  He outlined his ideals and projects in his manifesto Complexity and Contradiction in Architecture.


Complexity and Contradiction in Architecture was written by Robert Venturi as a criticism of modern architecture and an explanation of his views on the postmodernist movement.

Modern architects like Le Corbusier and Robert Venturi were critical of the social and urban effects of these designs, which is why they decided to critique it and to search for an architectural language that might overcome Modernism.

Taking into consideration the complexity achieved in past architectural designs, Venturi believed that the modernist movement in its attempt to break from tradition and start fresh, failed to maintain the intricacy in architecture. Therefore, in Venturi’s Complexity and Contradiction in Architecture he expounds on the reasons why the postmodernist movement revives this complexity in design.

Venturi demonstrates, through various designs, why he advocates the post modernist movement which attempts to include various requirements and their juxtapositions rather than the modernist approach of exclusion and separation.

We will highlight a selection of these buildings from Venturi’s book in an attempt to display his argument. These buildings include the (both-and) concept. This means that they embody contradiction and complexity in several ways, like the juxtaposition of a complex interior and a simple exterior, or the contrast between symmetry and asymmetry in one structure. These paradoxes result in a duality in plan, but create a unified space within the frame of contradiction.

The Venturi House

The Villa Savoye

Venturi’s Beach House

All three houses which Venturi highlights in his book share the elements of complexity and contradiction that he looks for in Postmodern designs. He criticizes the modernist movement and its failure to provoke the eye. The houses he highlights bring forward alternative and new elements used in a complex context which breaks free of the restrictions of modern architecture.